Best Aftershaves for Men for Painless Shaving and Attractive Skin
Aftershaves are misunderstood. Most men think they’re simply just colognes. They’re seen as unessential, expensive luxuries for men with too much money.
That, however, is nonsense.
They are an essential part of a proper shaving experience and can drastically change your skin condition for the better.
They help reduce the pain and ongoing chances of razor burn, razor cuts, ingrown hairs, and pseudofolliculitis barbae. Oh and most of the best aftershaves for men smell great! That’s always a bonus.
The ShavingNinja team has dug deep into consumer reviews to find the top choices for you so that you can make an informed purchase.
The Best Aftershaves for Men in 2019
Proraso After Shave Lotion
The Proraso After Shave Lotion is made from 98% natural ingredients to help keep skin in optimal condition.
Made in Italy, it’s designed to reduce inflammation and help with skin healing following razor burn, cuts or skin conditions.
It deploys a super quick cooling effect so that any itching sensations are dealt with quickly. It's one of the most effective aftershaves money can buy.
Pros:
Cons:
Type:
Lotion
Key Ingredient:
Witch Hazel
Fragrance:
Gentle Eucalyptus
Skin Type:
Normal Skin and Oily Skin
What Do Consumers Say:
78% of Amazon reviews are 5-star. Consumers claim it to be ‘simply the best’ and that it ‘leaves your skin feeling soft and gets rid of any irritation with that old school menthol feel but no overpowering scent!’
Our Rating:
This Proraso is a high-end department store type aftershave that is just a fraction of the price. Elegant and highly effective.
Gillette After Shave Gel
The Gillette After Shave Gel is one of the world’s top-selling best aftershaves for sensitive skin.
It’s relatively simple because it does two things - cools the skin and leaves a pleasant but not overwhelming smell.
It’s specifically made for sensitive skin users, so there is no risk of irritation or adverse reactions from the long-lasting gel.
Pros:
Cons:
Type:
Gel
Key Ingredient:
Water, Alcohol
Fragrance:
‘Manly’ Gillette smell
Skin Type:
Sensitive Skin
What Do Consumers Say:
79% of Amazon reviews are 5-star. Consumers say it’s ‘cool and subtle’ and will keep your skin rejuvenated and in top-condition with everyday use. One user states it won’t ‘leave your head still feeling dry, or itchy, or just sticky.’ Mostly, it is considered ‘Amazing value.
Our Rating:
In our personal opinion, natural ingredients are better, and that’s all that stops this very effective aftershave from getting 5-stars. You won’t find better value for money than with the 6-pack sold on Amazon.
Floris London No.89 After Shave Splash
So you want to smell like a million dollars? The top review on Amazon says “this will get you the babes.”
What we can tell you is that this is a luxury, high-end best smelling aftershave for men that will boost your confidence and invigorate your skin every morning.
Sold in the wealthy areas of London, this Floris aftershave has a blend of orange, bergamot, lavender, neroli and a touch of spicy nutmeg to give you a truly unique smell.
Oh and in the original James Bond novels, 007 used this fragrance.
Pros:
Cons:
Type:
Splash
Key Ingredient:
Water, Alcohol, Natural Products
Fragrance:
A luxury combination blend of orange, bergamot, lavender, neroli and a touch of spicy nutmeg.
Skin Type:
Normal skin and oily skin.
What Do Consumers Say:
79% of Amazon reviews are 5-star. Consumers say it’s ‘cool and subtle’ and will keep your skin rejuvenated and in top-condition with everyday use. One user states it won’t ‘leave your head still feeling dry, or itchy, or just sticky.’ Mostly it is considered ‘Amazing value.’
Our Rating:
In our personal opinion, natural ingredients are better, and that’s all that stops this very effective aftershave from getting 5-stars. You won’t find better value for money than with the 6-pack sold on Amazon.
Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel
No matter what razor blade you buy or electric shaver you use, skin irritation still happens. Ingrown hairs appear tired, shaving mistakes happen and worn out blades catch on the skin.
The Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel helps solve those problems so that you can carry on with your day without pain and discomfort.
As an alcohol-free, soothing lotion it focuses on relaxing your skin and cleaning the cuts without a stinging sensation!
Pros:
Cons:
Type:
Lotion/Gel
Key Ingredient:
All natural. Aloe Leaf and chamomile.
Fragrance:
A luxury combination blend of orange, bergamot, lavender, neroli and a touch of spicy nutmeg.
Skin Type:
All skin types.
Curvy facial hair.
What Do Consumers Say:
66% of Amazon reviews are 5*. Consumers say it is a godsend for delicate skin as it’s alcohol-free.
One user said “A little of it goes a long way, and one container can last weeks with just a dab on each side of the face. There is a refreshing initial aroma which rapidly clears.
This has become my go-to product after years with other brands.”
Our Rating:
This isn’t a fragrance; it’s a skin-care focused lifesaver. The consumer reviews prove it. You can’t beat it.
NIVEA Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm
NIVEA might be relatively new to the US market but has been one of the leading suppliers of men’s shaving products in Europe for decades.
Their post shave balm gives dry skin users an ultra-hydrating post-shave remedy that is highly effective in tightening the pores of your skin.
As an alcohol-free aftershave, it has been tested on men with sensitive skin and works to improve skin condition over time.
Pros:
Cons:
Type:
Balm
Key Ingredient:
Natural - Chamomile and Witch Hazel
Fragrance:
Super clean, fresh smell.
Skin Type:
Dry Skin, Sensitive Skin and Normal Skin
What Do Consumers Say:
79% of Amazon reviews are 5-star. An impressive score.
Consumers comment on how it works wonders to reduce irritation and provide a lightly scented “shower clean” smell. One user said “This stuff is liquid gold for my face.
No more irritation or dry, itchy skin! Doesn't leave a greasy residue either. Very happy with this product.”
Our Rating:
ShavingNinja believes this is the great choice in a balm form. It’ll work wonders for anyone with dry or sensitive skin, both visually and with pain.
